19
Feb
2007

Human Rights

Last year Giammattei, Guatemalan Penitentiary System Director, took over "Pavón", a prison that was basically ruled by it's prisoners. It took 1.700 agents, 1.200 soldiers and 100 guards to achieve full control of the facilities. Around ten prisoners died, casually the most known "leaders".

I found the general public opinion surprising. I mean, I was certainly happy to know the prison was once again under control; it had been in an anarchy state for over 10 years. But what shocked me was that people seemed pleased, almost glad to know prisoners had died. Giammattei's popularity went up like bubbles do when a menthos is dropped into a glass of coca-cola. Giammattei is now running for President in this year's elections.

I know that hard measures most be applied on hard situations. I myself questioned my own personal view and interpretation of what had happened; it seemed pretty clear to me that the dead prisoners were murdered intentionally, not by accident. Still, I felt some kind of relief. I was almost glad, like all those people I had talked to. But then- I started thinking about Human Rights. It's so complex. And even though I don't completely understand basically anything human related, I realized it was wrong.

It's wrong because you can't defend something by violating it, I think. Thinking over this a phrase I heard in Warner Bros TV series "Justice" came to my mind: "Justice is like hot dogs. If you like it, you shouldn't know how it's done" or something like that. I know I may fail to be an idealist by saying this, but I have to disagree.

I like to think justice can be transparent and morally correct. Defending the law by breaking it, revenging human rights's violations by violating basic human rights... it doesn't seem right.

And this post doesn't mean that I don't like Giammattei. It's not a political opinion, but more like a personal attempt to comprehend complex realities such as this. I don't wish to judge anyone, I wouldn't know how.
logo

yo no sé nada

Users Status

You are not logged in.

Recent Updates

Muchisimas gracias!
Hola animalamororum! Muchas gracias por tus comentarios...
rocio - 25. Feb, 11:28
Muchisimas gracias!
Hola animalamororum! Muchas gracias por tus comentarios...
rocio - 25. Feb, 11:28
Escritora
Que bien escribe. Yo leo bastante, pero rara vez termino...
animalamororum - 25. Jan, 01:02
RWT
Disculpe la pregunta, el texto inicial firmado RWT,...
animalamororum - 25. Jan, 00:54
Hoy 24 de Enero 2011
Hoy 24 de Enero 2011, vivi un dia en que concluyo esto...
animalamororum - 25. Jan, 00:50

Links

currently reading


Andres Oppenheimer
Cuentos chinos

About the books

Search

 

Status

Online for 6917 days
Last update: 14. Jul, 18:09

Credits


Profil
Logout
Subscribe Weblog